Altmetrics: Metrics Or Index?
An interview with Catherine Williams
past times Cristina Rigutto
"Altmetrics is the creation too study of novel metrics based on the Social Web for analysing, too informing scholarship." Jason Priem, 2010"Altmetrics are an indicator of engagement too a real-time tape of the online attending surrounding an private inquiry output." Catherine Williams, 2016
Is altmetrics a suite of metrics for inquiry affect evaluation based on information from the social spider web that is going to disrupt the primacy of citation-based metrics? Or is it an indicator of how a inquiry is connecting with its target audiences after publication information that helps researchers to position potential affect stories too assemble evidence for instance studies?
To response this inquiry (and a few more), I interviewed Catherine Williams, Chief Marketing Officer at Altmetric.
Dear Catherine, are altmetrics aiming to complement or to supersede traditional bibliographic rankings?
Altmetrics are real much intended to complement traditional scholarly metrics, such equally citations, to supply a to a greater extent than consummate moving painting of the laissez passer too potential broader impacts of a slice of research. Whereas citations reverberate the scholarly influence of the work, altmetrics tin ship away assist readers sympathise how it has been received too interpreted with a much broader audience - for illustration with policy makers, practitioners, too the full general public.
Most move inward altmetrics has been done comparison unlike social media indicators (e.g. mentions inward tweets) to citation measures. Does this move give us information almost success or almost impact? Or both?
There have got been several studies that have got tried to create upward one's demand heed if in that place is whatsoever correlation betwixt online attending too subsequent scholarly citations of a publication. Most of these have got concluded that if the correlation exists at all it is relatively weak - the i exception to this existence the issue of Mendeley readers (likely because if an academic saves an item to their Mendeley library it is non odd that they would hence afterwards read too so cite it).
With whatsoever mensurate (including citations) what they are interpreted to dot volition truly depend on the aims of the private researcher - for illustration if your objective was to growth world agreement of a sure enough theme so altmetrics that showed a lot of world engagement on social media too references from Wikipedia would supply a positive indicator that you lot had achieved your objective to some extent.
In most cases, all inquiry metrics (altmetrics, citations, downloads etc) only human activeness equally an indicator - they are a means of identifying where in that place mightiness inward hereafter move real-world impacts equally a direct resultant of the research.
Altmetrics are real much intended to complement traditional scholarly metrics, such equally citations, to supply a to a greater extent than consummate moving painting of the laissez passer too potential broader impacts of a slice of research. Whereas citations reverberate the scholarly influence of the work, altmetrics tin ship away assist readers sympathise how it has been received too interpreted with a much broader audience - for illustration with policy makers, practitioners, too the full general public. Most move inward altmetrics has been done comparison unlike social media indicators (e.g. mentions inward tweets) to citation measures. Does this move give us information almost success or almost impact? Or both?
There have got been several studies that have got tried to create upward one's demand heed if in that place is whatsoever correlation betwixt online attending too subsequent scholarly citations of a publication. Most of these have got concluded that if the correlation exists at all it is relatively weak - the i exception to this existence the issue of Mendeley readers (likely because if an academic saves an item to their Mendeley library it is non odd that they would hence afterwards read too so cite it).
With whatsoever mensurate (including citations) what they are interpreted to dot volition truly depend on the aims of the private researcher - for illustration if your objective was to growth world agreement of a sure enough theme so altmetrics that showed a lot of world engagement on social media too references from Wikipedia would supply a positive indicator that you lot had achieved your objective to some extent.
In most cases, all inquiry metrics (altmetrics, citations, downloads etc) only human activeness equally an indicator - they are a means of identifying where in that place mightiness inward hereafter move real-world impacts equally a direct resultant of the research.
The only means to truly know this is to teach too read the actual mentions - to encounter who is proverb what, too why. The details page provided past times altmetrics provider Altmetric enables you lot to practise just this; to persuasion too click through to all of the master copy mentions too shares of a publication. Remember, attention, similar citations, tin ship away move for both positive too negative reasons!
Does the role of social media metrics for evaluation create undesired incentives?
Social media metrics, such equally counts of Tweets or Facebook shares, should never move used inward isolation equally component subdivision of an evaluation process. These counts instead should move used to position where in that place is a bigger flush worth investigating, too so the qualitative information (what people are truly saying) tin ship away move used to evidence how the move has been received too interpreted with a broader audience.
How tin ship away altmetrics move used to monitor the effects of scientific discipline communication activities?
Journal article pages frequently include Altmetric badges which tin ship away move used to rail the dissemination of inquiry with many unlike sources, including the mainstream too social media, blogs too Wikipedia, equally good equally academic forums such equally F1000 too post-publication peer review sites Pubpeer too Publons.
Clicking on the badges volition present a tape of all of the mentions too shares of the research. These mentions are picked upward from the dot of publication onwards, pregnant that users tin ship away rail the attending inward existent fourth dimension too position which channels are generating the most engagement. Exploring the altmetrics for other items inward your plain may also assist you lot position primal influencers who could assist growth the visibility of your work, or sympathise which sources too communities are probable to move most interested.
How tin ship away altmetrics assist to railroad train hereafter communication strategies?
Altmetrics tin ship away straight off move found (often via the Altmetric badge) on thousands of magazine articles too other inquiry items. Researchers tin ship away explore the altmetrics for other items published inward their field, or inward the same journal, to encounter where those publications are getting attending from – for illustration in that place may move special groups or bloggers it would move worth engaging with to brand them aware of your work. Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 large practise goodness of altmetrics information is that it updates inward existent fourth dimension – so you lot speedily position where whatsoever outreach efforts are having an effect, too what changes it mightiness move worth making inward future.
Can altmetrics move changed past times self-promotion?
Yes, too that's non a bad thing! Getting your move noticed is something that should move encouraged - specially if you lot tin ship away create a strategy to to a greater extent than straight target the people you lot are most concerned should encounter it (key policy makers or patient groups, perhaps).
Altmetric calculate an attention score that provides an indicator of the bulk too probable laissez passer of the attending an item has received (the to a greater extent than attention, the higher the score), but because all mentions of the move are so transparent (via the details page) users volition move able to encounter where the writer has shared their move too also where it is receiving attending independently of that.
Some tips for how you lot mightiness showtime making your inquiry to a greater extent than visible are available in this guide.
Yes, too that's non a bad thing! Getting your move noticed is something that should move encouraged - specially if you lot tin ship away create a strategy to to a greater extent than straight target the people you lot are most concerned should encounter it (key policy makers or patient groups, perhaps).
Altmetric calculate an attention score that provides an indicator of the bulk too probable laissez passer of the attending an item has received (the to a greater extent than attention, the higher the score), but because all mentions of the move are so transparent (via the details page) users volition move able to encounter where the writer has shared their move too also where it is receiving attending independently of that.
Some tips for how you lot mightiness showtime making your inquiry to a greater extent than visible are available in this guide.
Are in that place whatsoever Countries where the credence of novel technologies too models for mensuration of scholarly influence is specially low?
The bulk of altmetrics are for the 2nd somewhat biased towards western sources too publications. This is because western networks (such equally Twitter too Facebook) have got processes inward house for making their information available, too also because many of the text-mining mechanisms currently inward house business office best on English-language publications.
That said, altmetrics already offering a large chance for inquiry that is underrepresented past times scholarly citation measures alone; some South American journals, for example, have a lot of engagement that is improve reflected through altmetrics than through whatsoever afterwards citations.
Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 study conducted past times Digital Science inward 2015 explored variations inward the means geographies too networks shared medical inquiry online – with some interesting conclusions!
Last but non least, what are the benefits to scholars of incorporating altmetrics inward a CV?
Embedding altmetrics tools such equally the Altmetric badges or fifty-fifty just summarising some of the information inward your CV offers some groovy advantages:
The bulk of altmetrics are for the 2nd somewhat biased towards western sources too publications. This is because western networks (such equally Twitter too Facebook) have got processes inward house for making their information available, too also because many of the text-mining mechanisms currently inward house business office best on English-language publications.
That said, altmetrics already offering a large chance for inquiry that is underrepresented past times scholarly citation measures alone; some South American journals, for example, have a lot of engagement that is improve reflected through altmetrics than through whatsoever afterwards citations.
Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 study conducted past times Digital Science inward 2015 explored variations inward the means geographies too networks shared medical inquiry online – with some interesting conclusions!
Last but non least, what are the benefits to scholars of incorporating altmetrics inward a CV?
Embedding altmetrics tools such equally the Altmetric badges or fifty-fifty just summarising some of the information inward your CV offers some groovy advantages:
- Adding context to your move – showcasing what people are proverb almost your publication tin ship away assist readers sympathise its potential hereafter impacts.
- Demonstrating laissez passer too influence – altmetrics insights tin ship away move specially useful for finding examples to cite when applying for funding or reviewing previous outputs with your supervisor.
- Encouraging farther engagement – making the altmetrics for your move available shows that you lot are both aware of too opened upward to give-and-take of it, encouraging others to interact with it too.
- Building your professional person profile – establishing yourself inward your field, specially equally an early-career researcher, tin ship away move a challenge. Altmetrics supply a unlike means of getting yourself noticed too evidencing the laissez passer of your move with your peers.
- Managing your reputation – because altmetrics information is tracked inward real-time, it’s quick too tardily to move on an optic on what’s existence said – pregnant you lot tin ship away footstep inward early on if anything is existence misrepresented or misinterpreted.
Catherine Williams is Chief Marketing Officer at Altmetric, a Digital Science fellowship that rail mentions of inquiry inward non-traditional sources to assist authors, publishers, institutions too funders monitor too study on the online activeness surrounding their work.
Follow @catherinelucy
Follow @altmetric
Comments
Post a Comment